So as for my personal feelings on the matter, I do try to see both sides, and I’m very aware of r/SapphoAndHerFriend type stories haha. When asking to take the relationship between Frodo and Sam at face value, it is only fair to also take the wish for lgbt+ representation at face value, without searching for ulterior motives, isn’t it? I was about to add another comment asking OP whether it really had to be all toxic masculinity, or if it could be just a personal wish for representation in most cases. I hope that makes some sense! And thank you very much for your thoughtful comment, even though we seem to disagree there's a lot of knee-jerk dismissiveness on this thread that doesn't really advanced the discussion. So it's less about denying platonic friendship, and more about yearning for people in media who Are Like Me. I'm sure the stans exist, but Merry/Pippin doesn't have nearly the same hold on the collective psyche as Frodo/Sam does. It's not that nobody can have close platonic friendships. Tolkien's writing is already of the best quality so it's fair for fans to want to catch glimpses of kinship in the characters there, even when it's not canon. It's taking the world a little while to catch up with queer people being allowed to, like, live so while we do have representation now, it's patchy and not always of the best quality. Instead, they're desperately looking for representation in the media they consume. The people who do these ships aren't saying it's impossible for straight men to have close friendships (though given the way people talk, I can understand why it might come across that way - look at r/SapphoAndHerFriend for a prime example of this). I think your first sentence here hints at the disconnect. Someone said Frodo could very well be gay, and I can see that, also if you want to ship Legolas and Gimli, go for it, make their competition have sexual tension instead of it being more racially based.Īlso since some of you seem to ask, I follow LOTR on Twitter, so I see pretty much any tweet relating to it, it seems like 50% are talking about Sam and Frodo in a gay relationship as cannon, not in fanfic. I think it bothers me because I'm a relatively emotional guy and dealt with a lot of gay jokes growing up because of that toxic masculinity, and saw the fellowship as representation that "men" can have feelings too, so to just ship the characters as a gay relationship kind of confirms the taxi views. Thank you for the comments, a lot of you understand where I'm coming from without any hate and some made great points. Just to reiterate, this isn't from a homophobic place, if the characters were gay, that's fine, i see it more as toxic masculinity. I ranted to my GF about it, but she doesn't care as much so I wanted to know how this community feels. To me it takes away from the characters in the same way that men can't be real friends with women because they just want to sleep with them. Not coming from a homophobic point of view, but the male characters all show love and affection towards each other, caring about each other and showing emotional vulnerability, and to reduce that friendship to "oh it's because they are gay" I see it as a form toxic masculinity that the only way for men to have emotions and care for each other is "because gay" Personally I hate it, and I think the idea actually ruins the relationship. I've seen a lot of posts on Twitter recently of people trying to ship Frodo and Sam together saying that they are clearly gay and a couple (I see it alot from LGBT users) and I wanted to know your thoughts. If you are discussing something new, such as the recent Hobbit movies, please use spoiler tags as follows: (/spoiler)Īnd remember NOT to put spoilers in your post titles! If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world! Legolas, Aragorn and Gimli Snoos created by Tom Sexton LoTR - Wikipedia Page Spoiler Tags - USE THEM! Tolkien Related Multi-Reddit to Rule them All Recommended Sites The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth Beorhthelm's Sonįor a full recommended Tolkien reading list, please CLICK HERE - written by ebneter Related Subreddits.Lord Of The Rings (Including Appendices).Don't Criticize Others For Their Opinionsĭetails of rules are HERE Tolkien Recommended Reading.For all things Tolkien, The Lord Of The Rings, The Hobbit, Silmarillion, and more.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |